Janie Sullivan – Emma Sue’s Angels

OK, so for Clean Up Your Writing Files Day I scrounged around in my files and found this story. It needed cleaning up, so I did. Then I entered it in the Spring, 2012 WOW Flash Fiction Contest. Unfortunately, it did not win. However, I did order a critique, which should be coming along any day now. Read the story and let me know what you think – then when I get the critique, I will post it here – so we can all learn from it.

Emma Sue’s Angels

When folks sat around and talked about that summer, they always said the same thing: “It was unseasonable hot that year.” When I heard that, I knew they were going to start talking about Emma Sue, the sister that disappeared.

Emma Sue was five years old that summer. She was small for her age, and kind of sickly, but that did not stop Mamm from expecting her to pull her own weight in the fields, just like the rest of us. There was six of us, all girls. I was the oldest at 12. Emma Sue was not the youngest, that was Polly Mae, she was three. We all worked in the fields, picking celery. It was hard work, cutting those tough stalks right at the base. Mamm would not let the younger ones have the sharpest knives because she was afraid they would cut themselves, but it was harder to cut celery with the dull knives.

Emma Sue especially hated it and was always sneaking off to play in the rows between the stalks. She had a great imagination and she was always talking about playing with angels in between the celery rows. We figured that was just talk, Emma Sue making stuff up so she would not get in trouble when she ran off to play. Mamm loved angels and she did not fault Emma Sue for wanting to play with them.

“Emma Sue!” Mamm called quietly so the foreman would not hear her and know that Emma Sue was missing again. “Where have you gotten to? You are way behind in your cutting. You come out now, hear me?” Mamm looked around but could not see Emma Sue’s faded blue bonnet poking up above the rows of celery. She could see everyone else bent over in the fields, busily hacking at the base of the plants, but not Emma Sue.

“Now where has that girl gotten herself to?” Mamm muttered as she tried to keep looking while she kept slicing at the celery plants. “She is going to get a whupping for certain when she comes back.”

We all kept working; the foreman was mean and we did not want to feel his whip lashing our backs as we worked under the hot sun. It wouldn’t be long before we stopped for our bread and cheese lunch, so we just wiped the stinging sweat out of our eyes and kept on cutting celery, listening for the whistle so we could stop to eat.

Emma Sue was still missing when the whistle finally signaled our lunch break. Mamm looked all up and down the rows, calling her name over and over. The only one who had not been bent over in the celery rows all morning was the foreman on top his big horse. Mamm finally got up the courage to ask him if he saw Emma Sue slip away.

“Nah, that girl is slick. She proll’y ran away. Don’t matter much, though, y’all still has to pick the same …Emma Sue or not.” The foreman trotted off toward the shade and a cool drink, leaving Mamm standing alone in the field.

“Mamm!” Polly Mae said, “Pretty!” We all looked out at the celery field to where she was pointing. A huge pair of white wings beat slowly just above the tops of the celery. Suddenly, they started glowing white-gold, so bright we had to look away. When we looked back, they were gone.

Nobody ever saw Emma Sue again.

 

3 thoughts on “Janie Sullivan – Emma Sue’s Angels

  1. I love the story, but I have to agree with the comments. Story content, voice, and style are all strong, but I felt that contractions would have blended better with the informal setting. I enjoyed the story from beginning to end. Good job. Try again.

  2. Here is the critique from WOW. It looks like they were really picky on the technical aspect. And that is fine. I might have won had I not had those three little problems.

    CRITIQUE

    Scores: 1-5 (5 being strongest):
    Subject: 5
    Content: 5
    Technical: 2

    OPEN PROMPT (Any genre in fiction)
    Word Count: 750 max

    SUMMARY

    Subject (Is it fiction? Appropriate for WOW! readers? Brief summary):

    The story is fiction and appropriate for WOW! readers. A young girl disappears and was never seen again

    Content (Is the story well developed? Is there a plot/point to the story? Is it compelling? Are the characters well-drawn?)

    Plot/point: There is a plot/point to the story
    Compelling: It is compelling because of the tension
    Characters: We know enough about the characters to carry the story

    Technical (Did they follow the rules–is there a title and proper word count? Check for proper spelling, punctuation and grammar, correct tense, active not passive sentences, overuse of adverbs, use of “wrylies”):

    Title: There is a title and it is appropriate
    Word count: 582 words

    Dialogue: The dialogue is good
    Past tense/passive voice: This is written in active voice
    Word choice/word usage: The word “unseasonable” should be “unseasonably”
    Adverbs/adjectives: There are no adverbs or adjectives that stand out
    Grammar/punctuation: The ellipses have no spaces before or after…like this
    Unnecessary words: There are no unnecessary words
    Phrases: There is one awkward phrase—I think it might be because of “keep” and “kept”
    Clichés: There are no overused clichés

    Overview (This is where you give your general impression about the writing style, how the story affected you, etc.):

    I really liked your story! You did a great job with the setting and a description of the family and what their job was. I also liked the characterization of the foreman, and how mean he was. Emma Sue sounds like a wonderful girl with a wonderful imagination. You had me thinking the foreman did something to her, but I think your ending is much better. It paints a nice picture and leaves a rather good feeling. Nicely done!

Leave a comment